Stealing Back The Commons: Citizen Economics Beyond Capitalism (Part One)

by JULES PECK on Feb 27, 2013 • 7:45 pm2 Comments
Michael Jacobs, an ex-SpAd to Gordon Brown, has recently written in the New Satesman that ‘green social democracy can save capitalism’. Well, not everyone agrees. For some, the ‘green social democracy’ experiment has, thus far, not worked, and indeed, might be running out of time.

And as for capitalism – or at least capitalism1.0, it’s no longer heresy to question its infallibility. Since we last blogged about capitalism, a host of mainstreamers like the BBC’s Stephanie Flanders, the FT’s Martin Wolf, UBS’s George Magnus, Joseph Stiglitz and Nouriel Roubini, have started questioning our growth-obsessed, capitalist economics and calling up Karl Marx from his grave.

And, as a search of Amazon will show you, there’s no shortage of recent books both questioning capitalism and laying out ideas for its updating or replacement.

But why might we have to consider alternatives to capitalism and what might an alternative look like?

Limits to growth

As we’ve mentioned often on this site, people like Professors Tim Jackson and Herman Daly has shown that, due to the scale and urgency required to tackle things like climate change, technological solutions to ‘decoupling’ growth from carbon emissions are nothing short of delusional.

So its becoming clear that continued growth of the macro economy would push us into climate meltdown and commit the world’s poorest and our children to unthinkable trauma. As someone I’m now working with, IPCC scientist and Deputy Director of the Tyndall Centre Professor Kevin Anderson, recently said, “we can either deal with climate change or have a growth economy – not both.”

Economist Kenneth Boulding famously said pretty much the same thing, now being repeated by finance brokers Tullet Prebon, “to believe in infinite growth on a finite planet you have to either be an economist or a madman.” In any case, whether we want to keep growing or not may be out of our hands, as writer Richard Heinberg points out “growth is over, like it or not.”

The good news is that emerging macro-economic modelling from the New Economics Foundation (Nef) and by Professors Peter Victor and Tim Jackson is showing that an end to global economic expansion needn’t stop us delivering high employment, high wellbeing and fiscal balance.

In other words, there is hope that the rich world can well afford to find a quantitative reverse gear so that the poor world can hopefully continue to develop qualitatively.

But what are the implications for our current economic-incumbent capitalism?

Some would argue that capitalism has played a role, along with other forms of market and non-market socio-economics, in historic improvements in material and non-material wellbeing. But capitalism brings with it endless ‘externalities’, as historian Mike Davis argues in the fascinating Late Victorian Holocausts, “Millions died in the golden age of Liberal Capitalism; indeed, many were murdered … by the theological application of the sacred principles of Smith, Bentham and Mill.”

For todays ‘full-world’ challenges, a new, or radically updated system is needed. This new economics will need to deliver two key things. It will need to deliver wellbeing to all, current and future generations. And it will need to do that sustainably. Call it ‘sustainable wellbeing economics’.

The problem for capitalism, as it jockeys for position as our preferred economic model for the next 300 years, is that it relies on continued and exponential economic growth to support the dynamic of profit maximisation and the ‘treadmill of accumulation’.

Attempts at incremental reform of capitalism – Michael Jacobs’ ‘green social democracy’ and other models such as ‘market ecology’, ‘natural capitalism’ and ‘capitalism-as-if-the-earth-matters’ have failed. Eco-socialists will say they were always doomed to fail. Others that they might have worked if given more time.

But time is something we don’t have. NASAs climatologist James Hansen says “we may already be too late’. Kevin Anderson that, without urgent change we’re locked into 4 degrees of warming . As we blogged recently, that’s scientist-speak for apocalypse.

As our current economics continues to unravel towards ‘peak money’ and social unrest, with the pain of real austerity hitting Greek citizens, and with the Red Cross giving out food parcels in Spain, where there are now 2.3m ‘vulnerable’ people, many are asking ‘are we next?’

There are of course alternatives to pure free-market capitalism. Red-in-tooth-and-claw Anglo-Saxon capitalism is just a more extreme version of variants such as European Social Democracy, Asian mixed economy and Keiretsu capitalism. But no form of capitalism has ever been able to sustainably provide ‘good lives’ for all. And certainly never been able to, nor could ever, operate without growth.

In part two of this blog we look at what might replace or update capitalism 1.0.

Related Posts
Stealing Back The Commons: Citizen Economics Beyond Capitalism (Part Two)
Debunking the Tragedy of the Commons
Res Communes – the rise of citizen-led, fair-market, alternatives to capitalism
Comedy of the Commons?
Is George Osborne questioning capitalism?
Previous post
Nick Clegg’s Failure is the Failure to Ask The Right Questions
Next post
Stealing Back The Commons: Citizen Economics Beyond Capitalism (Part Two)

SOCIAL LINKS
RSS Feed
Twitter
followers
ABOUT CITIZEN RENAISSANCE
Citizen Renaissance was conceived by Jules Peck and Robert Phillips in the spring of 2008 – on the eve of the global economic crisis and before The Big Society had really seen the light of day. Originally published as a wiki, Citizen Renaissance explores the collision of the three seismic shifts of our time: the perfect storm surrounding Climate Change; the Wellbeing Imperative; and the axiomatic rise of Digital Democracy. At its heart lies a call for more citizen-centric thinking and behaviour and an end to the global imbalance of Wants & Needs. Citizen Renaissance continues today as a forum for thought; a platform for the exchange of ideas; and as a collaborative project that seeks to develop a Manifesto for Change.
THE AUTHORS
Jules Peck was Director of David Cameron’s Quality of Life Policy Group, advising the Conservative Party on wellbeing and environment issues.
Robert Phillips is a Writer and Thinker. He was previously President & CEO, EMEA, of Edelman, the world’s largest Public Relations firm. Although a committed workaholic and Manchester United fan, Robert is still determined to change the world in his spare time.
DOWNLOAD THE BOOK
Your Name
Your Email

RECENT POSTS
framework-275
Stealing Back The Commons: Citizen Economics Beyond Capitalism (Part Two)
Mar 4, 2013
Unknown
Stealing Back The Commons: Citizen Economics Beyond Capitalism (Part One)
Feb 27, 2013
0_285_427_http-__offlinehbpl.hbpl.co.uk_news_OWM_1098FE13-95C4-BDE3-2E5CBF87C8948715
Nick Clegg’s Failure is the Failure to Ask The Right Questions
Feb 25, 2013
moon1
World Gone Wrong
Feb 20, 2013
imgres
Stop Swaying. Start Shifting
Feb 5, 2013
BLOGROLL
Arkism
Chattering Class
Comment Central
CrowdSurfing
Demos
Force for Good
goodpurpose Community
Iain Dale’s Diary
Nick Robinson
Politics of Wellbeing
Richard Sambrook: The World at Large
Steffen’s blog
Valuing Nature
Web Cameron
Worldchanging